"WHAT IF...?"
"I think 'What if...?' questions regarding our personal lives often don't make much sense. Of course, it also depends on the reason we are asking this question. For example, if we want to analyze a past situation where we feel we could have done something differently—perhaps better—and we want to think through the possibilities of 'what if' we had acted differently, what the outcome of the event would have been, or how we or others involved would have felt, then it might make sense. Especially if we ask this question with the intention of learning or improving something (say, ourselves 😊).
However, if we ask this question out of self-pity, we won't get anywhere, except that we will feel very sorry for ourselves or resent others who were involved in the situation. This way, we only maintain the unfortunate state we are suffering in. So, I think if this question comes up, it's worth looking at why we are asking it right now, and it would be really good if we could answer ourselves honestly. Then we could spare ourselves, and probably others too, a lot of suffering. I've noticed that this question often stems from resentment, guilt, and an inability to accept something. In such cases, it can take us to very dark places.
But there are times, for instance—and no one will ever be able to tell us this, or rather, many might try, but it's best to listen to our own inner voice—when we don't know if we are doing the right thing or not. We don't know whether to do what we want to do the most, yet we don't do it for many reasons, and suddenly this question pops up: 'What if... I do it? Or what would happen if I did it?'
Let me give you a very mundane example from my own life. I'm walking home from grocery shopping, and a man (probably a very poor man) is begging, sitting on the ground. As I pass by, he asks me for money. Usually, I just give him a kind smile (with a bit of pity, because I don't have too much to give either) and keep walking. But! Today, as I walk on, the question crosses my mind: 'What if I gave him some little thing after all?'
And I'm still slowly moving forward, walking away from the man, thinking, yes, why couldn't I give him something, since I have a little change today that I'd gladly give away. So I turn around, take a little money out of my wallet, go up to the man sitting on the ground, and give it to him. And I walk home. And I don't even think about it anymore. I gave it because I wanted to give it, and I no longer dwell on 'What if I had given it to him (because I hadn't)?' or what he will use the money for. That's it, it's done, I gave it. I am okay with myself.
Now, however, it occurred to me that sometimes it's better to focus on 'What is?' rather than 'What if...?'. Yes, there are a lot of things right here in front of us that are. So how much more interesting it is to deal with those, instead of daydreaming about what isn't. Because, you see, 'What would happen if...?' and 'What if...?' are all conditional modes... meaning something that isn't, wasn't, or won't even be... etc.
But still, as I mentioned earlier, sometimes it makes sense to ask these questions too, if we feel they help us move forward. For example, imagining difficult situations to train ourselves to step out—at least in our imagination—of the fear that stops us from acting the way we truly want to deep down. I think that makes sense.